A lawyer used ChatGPT and now has to answer for its ‘bogus’ citations

by Research Desk Posted on

Lawyers suing the Colombian airline Avianca submitted a brief full of previous cases that were just made up by ChatGPT, The New York Times reported today. After opposing counsel pointed out the nonexistent cases, US District Judge Kevin Castel confirmed, “Six of the submitted cases appear to be bogus judicial decisions with bogus quotes and bogus internal citations,” and set up a hearing as he considers sanctions for the plaintiff’s lawyers.

Lawyer Steven A. Schwartz admitted in an affidavit that he had used OpenAI’s chatbot for his research. To verify the cases, he did the only reasonable thing: he asked the chatbot if it was lying.

When he asked for a source, ChatGPT went on to apologize for earlier confusion and insisted the case was real, saying it could be found on Westlaw and LexisNexis. Satisfied, he asked if the other cases were fake, and ChatGPT maintained they were all real.

The opposing counsel made the court aware of the issue in painful detail as it recounted how the Levidow, Levidow & Oberman lawyers’ submission was a brief full of lies. In one example, a nonexistent case called Varghese v. China Southern Airlines Co., Ltd., the chatbot appeared to reference another real case, Zicherman v. Korean Air Lines Co., Ltd.., but got the date (and other details) wrong, saying it was decided 12 years after its original 1996 decision.

Schwartz says he was “unaware of the possibility that its content could be false.” He now “greatly regrets having utilized generative artificial intelligence to supplement the legal research performed herein and will never do so in the future without absolute verification of its authenticity.”

Schwartz isn’t admitted to practice in the Southern District of New York but originally filed the lawsuit before it was moved to that court and says he continued to work on it. Another attorney at the same firm, Peter LoDuca, became the attorney of record on the case, and he will have to appear in front of the judge to explain just what happened.

83 thoughts on “A lawyer used ChatGPT and now has to answer for its ‘bogus’ citations”

  7. I’ve been surfing on-line greater than three hours lately, but I never discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours. It?¦s beautiful value sufficient for me. In my opinion, if all web owners and bloggers made just right content as you probably did, the web shall be much more useful than ever before.

    Reply

  13. I wish to convey my appreciation for your kindness giving support to folks that absolutely need assistance with the concern. Your special commitment to passing the solution throughout was unbelievably useful and have constantly allowed regular people much like me to reach their objectives. Your own important information entails so much a person like me and extremely more to my fellow workers. Many thanks; from each one of us.

    Reply

  14. I precisely needed to thank you so much once more. I am not sure what I might have accomplished in the absence of these thoughts revealed by you relating to this question. Certainly was a real daunting problem for me, however , noticing a skilled style you processed the issue made me to weep for joy. Extremely happier for the service and even hope you really know what a powerful job you were doing educating most people with the aid of your website. Most probably you’ve never got to know any of us.

    Reply

  55. Beyond news reporting, BusinessIraq.com provides essential business resources including economic indicators, market research, and industry reports. Our platform maintains strong relationships with chambers of commerce, government agencies, and industry associations to ensure accurate and timely information. Whether you’re a local entrepreneur, international investor, or market analyst, our comprehensive coverage helps you make informed decisions in Iraq’s dynamic business landscape.

    Reply

  57. Understanding the complexities of Iraq’s market, BusinessIraq.com offers specialized reporting on trade policies, economic reforms, and market trends. Our platform features expert interviews with industry leaders, government officials, and economic analysts, providing valuable insights into Iraq’s business climate. Regular coverage of international partnerships, foreign investment initiatives, and cross-border trade agreements keeps our readers ahead of market developments.

    Reply

  66. A code promo 1xBet est un moyen populaire pour les parieurs d’obtenir des bonus exclusifs sur la plateforme de paris en ligne 1xBet. Ces codes promotionnels offrent divers avantages tels que des bonus de dépôt, des paris gratuits, et des réductions spéciales pour les nouveaux joueurs ainsi que les utilisateurs réguliers.le code promo de 1xbet

    Reply

  67. Great V I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your site. I had no trouble navigating through all tabs and related information ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or something, website theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Nice task..

    Reply

  70. I don’t think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.

    Reply

  76. Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?

    Reply
  77. Pingback: rybelsus 14 mg

  78. In comparison, whole testosterone by itself has no influence on physique composition; nevertheless,
    each of these readings will rise significantly
    when taking Dianabol. If an individual is discovered promoting steroids, the maximum punishment is
    5 years in prison and a $250,000 fine. Jail sentences and fines could be doubled if this can be a second offense.
    In 1958, Ziegler, with the assistance of CIBA (a Swiss pharmaceutical firm), launched Dianabol within the US after successfully submitting
    a patent for his or her new drug. Let’s get into
    what steroids are, what they’re used for (both legally and illegally), and how to find some safe options to steroids
    that’ll provide the same outcomes.
    Athletes and bodybuilders use stacking or combinations in a bid to optimize the results they’re hoping to achieve
    from their use. Tell your healthcare provider about all of your medicines, together with prescription and over-the-counter (OTC) medicine and nutritional vitamins or supplements.
    As A End Result Of of these risks, healthcare providers prescribe prednisone
    on the lowest efficient dose and for the shortest
    potential time. Steroids deal with situations such as
    bronchial asthma, rheumatoid arthritis (RA), lupus,
    a number of sclerosis (MS), eczema, several sorts of
    most cancers, Crohn’s illness, ulcerative colitis (UC),
    and others. Since dexamethasone and prednisone can treat
    varied medical circumstances, it is troublesome to determine which drug is usually
    more practical. Folks who turn into dependent on anabolic steroids can also have withdrawal signs if they cease taking them.

    In one examine, participants reached sleep 36% sooner after a single dose of valerian (38).

    A strategy to stop overstimulation is to take Anavar doses earlier
    within the day. Calorie consumption ought to be tailored to a user’s aims when cycling Anavar.
    Therefore, if Anavar is taken with the intention of bulking and gaining lean mass, then a
    small calorie surplus could additionally be adopted
    to enhance muscle and strength results. Clenbuterol is
    a beta-2 sympathomimetic and is usually used in the treatment of hypotension.
    Although corticosteroids are very important
    remedies, they arrive with a variety of potential unwanted side effects.
    Taking corticosteroids for an extended period of time,
    even if at a low dose, additionally will increase your likelihood of experiencing
    unwanted effects. It is important to understand that if you
    have been prescribed antibiotics, then it is a severe matter!
    Taking such medication throughout illness has a strong effect on the
    physique, so alcohol will only improve the load on the liver and different organs.
    There are a quantity of antibiotics that, when mixed with ethanol, turn out to be toxic.

    Symptoms of hypogonadism can embody gynecomastia (enlarged breast tissue), erectile dysfunction and infertility.
    Some of those signs may solely show up after you’ve stopped taking testosterone.
    Typically, the brief course of tapered steroids acts to break or decrease the intensity of the migraine episode.

    Corticosteroid therapy often works higher as a short-term remedy.
    For example, someone having a flare of rheumatoid arthritis would possibly have to
    take a short course of corticosteroids to help get their disease under control.
    Whereas they work nicely to regulate certain diseases, they’ll trigger several side effects, corresponding to elevated blood sugar ranges and weight achieve.
    For this purpose, they’re reserved only for reasonable to severe inflammatory situations (34).
    While AAS are probably the most generally talked-about kind of steroid, there could be another
    variety referred to as glucocorticoids or corticosteroids.

    Nonetheless, we find injectable Dianabol to be less frequent on the black
    market, with orals being the more standard form of administration. Some
    research have shown milk thistle to be efficient at lowering inflammation and reducing liver
    enzymes, especially in these affected by acute hepatitis.
    Nevertheless, other studies have shown combined
    outcomes, with no important profit when supplementing with milk thistle, particularly in individuals who have broken livers from utilizing hepatotoxic medication.
    1) How much prednisone is ok to take daily if I needed to for years to
    come? 2) How a lot Methotrexate do they give you before they cease upping the dose?

    3) I heard methotrexate stops working for some folks in time after a couple
    years, does this occur a lot? 4) Last, I truly have read some articles on promising remedy like shots etc.
    which of the following is least likely to be caused by abuse of anabolic steroids?
    (gitlab.sict.edu.mn) are about
    to enter human testing, do you think such cures like at companies like
    Garvan Institute might actually happen? I know this may be a lot of questions, but every time i
    strive to deliver things up to the Rhummy docs I see, they simply seem to want to
    rush you out to the subsequent affected person. Usually, a
    dose above 40 mg per day may be thought of a excessive dose of steroids.
    Nonetheless, it’s essential to notice that individuals reply in a unique way to the drug, and “high dosages” might
    vary relying on the person.
    You could be given a small dose, known as a upkeep dose,
    for a very long time to verify your signs don’t
    return. You will be given the lowest attainable dose for the shortest possible time,
    to reduce back the danger of unwanted effects.
    Your dose will probably be reduced gradually as your signs enhance, or
    your physician might suggest a weaker medication. Steroids may have an result on some medical conditions, corresponding to diabetes, coronary heart or blood stress issues, or mental
    well being issues. If you could have any of those situations, the individual treating you’ll need to ensure the steroids aren’t making the
    condition worse. If you go “cold turkey” off of prednisone,
    that’s a giant drawback. You need to slowly lower in dose till you’re again to closer to
    the 2.5 milligrams a day.
    If you’re still not feeling good after you cease taking prednisone, positively be in touch
    with your doctor since you may be going by way of prednisone
    withdrawals. Generally, if you’re solely taking five to 10
    days of prednisone, you don’t need to taper.
    Healthcare suppliers prescribe prednisone at the lowest effective dose and for the shortest attainable time.
    Whereas steroids like prednisone may help short-term,
    your healthcare supplier may suggest it as only one small part of a complete plan to manage the symptoms.
    Healthcare providers generally prescribe corticosteroids
    to adults and kids to deal with irritation as a end result of varied causes.
    Research present that few people who misuse anabolic steroids search
    therapy to stop utilizing them.

    Reply
  80. Pingback: clomid 50mg tablets

  83. One of the primary problems with most steroids available on the market is that they will trigger females to develop male
    bodily characteristics. In truth, a “V-shaped” physique with a broad
    upper half is what many bodybuilders goal to achieve via steroid
    consumption. Earlier Than we walk you thru the numerous transformation in individuals who have relied heavily on steroids to realize their physique objectives, allow us
    to first introduce you to steroids. When you think about ester weight
    with Testosterone Enanthate, 500 mg per week would possibly truly solely
    find yourself being between 300 – 350 mg of usable Testosterone.
    Perhaps even much less, and I will doubtless see how low I
    can get it earlier than I begin seeing muscle loss in the near future (androgens are
    one of the primary roots of coronary heart disease).
    This is why it’s so incredibly essential to fully perceive
    how to diet, prepare, and how to milk essentially the most muscle out of intelligent
    dosages as potential.
    Don’t even consider blasting and cruising in your first few
    cycles. Do common cycles and PCT, then take into consideration how you’d
    feel about injecting testosterone to retain normal hormonal operate for the remainder of your life.
    Your only possibility for hair loss prevention might be RU-58841, as Finasteride will have no influence.

    What some guys don’t understand is that SOME water retention is not essentially a nasty factor.
    Joints, particularly, can profit from some water,
    and if you want to add volume, then a little bit of fluid just isn’t at all times a unfavorable.
    Either of those go along with your chosen AI, which you can increase the dose of.
    This ought to work shortly and have those gyno symptoms reduced and reversed within just
    a few days.
    Secondly, and perhaps most significantly, this steroid is instrumental in selling lean muscle progress.
    Now, you may say other steroids do that too, but bear in mind, only a few can declare such effectiveness with minimal dangers of virilization (development of masculine features).
    Round week eight I observed a puffy nip and more water retention than regular.
    Being my first cycle, I was nervous about crashing my e2, but 12.5mg of aromasin twice every week on pin days worked properly.
    To mitigate danger I donated blood once a month, saved cardio in my routine, ate mostly healthy foods, monitored adjustments
    intently, and obtained bloodwork accomplished earlier
    than, throughout, and after cycle. A well-balanced food plan rich in protein, wholesome fat,
    advanced carbohydrates, and essential micronutrients can significantly impact hormonal stability for bodybuilders.

    CrazyBulk is our beneficial source for legal steroid options, primarily based on 1000’s of positive
    reviews on verified platforms similar to Trustpilot and Feefo.
    Anadrol, a steroid, is damaged down within the liver earlier than coming into the bloodstream.
    Heavy sweating can also be caused by testosterone esters, which have the capability to forestall sweat glands
    from secreting water.
    Likewise, they want to begin with the lowest really helpful dose and proceed the
    cycle for not extra than 4 to eight weeks. Equally, comply with the cycle with some form of
    post-cycle remedy to assist stabilize your hormone ranges.
    When it involves putting on muscle mass for a
    bulkier look, Anadrol is one steroid that stays on the must-have record of most bodybuilders.
    Unlike some other steroids on the record that are basically diuretic in nature, Anadrol is estrogenic, thereby causing extra water
    retention by the muscle cells. It may be mixed with anabolic steroids throughout cutting cycles due
    to its potent results on adrenaline and metabolism.

    Deca Durabolin, regardless of its recognition in fitness circles, isn’t without potential drawbacks.
    There are a couple of unwanted aspect effects that users should take
    notice of, so they can catch them early on and take applicable action.
    Also, customers are suggested to get their alanine transaminase (ALT) and aspartate transferase (AST) levels checked pre-cycle to make sure they’re in a standard
    range. Often, Anavar can flush out extracellular water and shuttle fluid contained in the muscle.

    When a person stops taking Anavar, they are unlikely to
    look as dry, with their muscle tissue being less full.
    Non-drug-tested powerlifters will nearly definitely cycle trenbolone previous
    to a competition. A user’s dosage and cycle period will also determine the results.

    Use HCG for the two weeks between stopping your cycle
    and starting PCT. This will put you in the
    most effective position to begin a SERM PCT to maintain features and restore natural testosterone.
    A commonplace HCG dose of 500iu every two days for 2 weeks is all you want to get these advantages.
    As A Result Of if you do blasting and cruising for
    a number of years, you run the risk of by no means regaining natural testosterone perform at the degree you had it previously.

    Due To This Fact, getting your T ranges and manufacturing again on track as quickly as potential after a Deca cycle is vital.
    This is the place your post-cycle remedy protocol is so essential, as regaining testosterone perform is likely one of the two big
    causes we do PCT (the other being to retain our hard-earned gains).
    The finest first cycle is testosterone only, so that you get a feel
    for steroids vs non Steroids.
    Ideally, the second cycle stack is Test and Deca, a superb combination. With a brief half-life,
    if virilization begins developing, you probably can give up and have that steroid exit your body comparatively quickly.
    NPP is a a lot faster-acting ester of Nandrolone and can kick off your cycle very properly.

    It’s still typically run for 16 weeks just because Nandrolone
    will give you slower and steadier gains than something like Dianabol.

    The answer seems like an apparent “sure,” and there’s a plethora of anecdotal proof to substantiate this.
    But this double-blind, placebo-controlled research solutions the
    question more objectively. In conclusion, armed with the data gleaned from this complete information,
    you’re well-prepared to initiate your first steroid cycle responsibly and effectively.
    By incorporating skilled steering, thoughtful planning, and
    a holistic life-style strategy, you set the stage for reaching your health aesthetics with confidence and
    long-term success. One Other noteworthy benefit of buying anabolic steroids on-line is the
    discreet and safe nature of the transaction course of.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Copyright © 2025, ExpertWhitepaper. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy.